A full replacement here is a tear off rather than a layover, and 2 of the 169 roofers listed in Milwaukee metro do them.
At a glance
- A tear off lets the roofer see the decking. A layover hides it.
- Ask for ice and water membrane at the eaves and in every valley.
- The quote should name the number of squares and the shingle line.
- Ventilation gets fixed during a replacement or it never gets fixed.
Highly rated roofers across the county
Ranked by rating and review count. Call two or three before you decide.
No 1
No 2
No 3
Infinity Exteriors
4.8 from 2,499 reviews
Highly reviewed25 years in business
Ridge Top Exteriors
4.8 from 1,041 reviews
Highly reviewedOpen 24 hours20 years in businessStreet address on fileWebsite
Tri-County Contracting
4.9 from 798 reviews
Highly reviewed45 years in businessStreet address on fileWebsite
Modern Exterior Roofing
4.9 from 731 reviews
Highly reviewed10 years in businessStreet address on fileWebsite
WeatherPro Exteriors
4.9 from 673 reviews
Highly reviewed15 years in businessStreet address on fileWebsite
J&J Contractors I LLC
4.9 from 584 reviews
Highly reviewed40 years in businessStreet address on fileWebsite
Guardian Home Improvements
4.8 from 504 reviews
Highly reviewedOpen 24 hours25 years in businessStreet address on fileWebsite
Exterior Pros
4.6 from 623 reviews
15 years in businessStreet address on fileWebsite
All Season Roofing
4.9 from 404 reviews
Highly reviewed15 years in businessStreet address on fileWebsite
Common questions
How long does a full roof replacement take
A typical house is one to three days once the crew is on site. Weather and a complicated roof shape stretch it.
What time of year is best for a new roof
Late spring through fall. Shingles need warmth to seal, so winter work is possible but often needs hand sealing.
How many squares is my roof
A square is 100 square feet of roof surface. A common house here lands between 20 and 35 squares once the pitch is counted.